The note "Herd Immunity" in Calamity Essentials III is still locked even though I have unlocked the prevoius notes and have enough and field guides and ministry manuals to upgrade it.
Please note - the answer to everyones’s question about HERD IMMUNITY is in the middle of page two from the HPWU team. It will only unlock from the left and not the right - which is completely illogical and perhaps if we continue to ask for clarification it may be changed. Why do some nodes open from left, right, up, or down but not this one??
If we have to unlock the node only from the left we need 70 DADA books which at the current rate would take 3-4 more months which doesn’t help anyone for this weekend’s event.
Sorry, I hate to be the bearer of bad news but just maybe we can get it changed?? Just maybe?? 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
more than disappointing. Not consistent with the rest of the game or nodes multi-directionality—part of the strategy of the game and use of field guides and manuals
wow. Debugging and game play should be clear and consistent at the least.
lots of energy and resources as well as time wasted.
@HPWUrobert I fully agree with the remarks @ClairabusGryff made about Herd Immunity - it is no good saying you can unlock it from the right (bllocked by loads of DADA books), when it clearly looks like it should also unlock from the left. That is how it works in 95%+ of other similar nodes.
Chasing waterfalls was incorrectly only open from only one approach but got fixed. Can this please be fixed as there is currently no logic to it? There are no arrows, all lines are equally valid, all should work including upwards. "Herd immunity" is super urgent for this weekend.
Hello, I've noticed a bug in SOS training in Polish version. There shows that there is greater chance of getting Exstimulo elixirs, but in description there is something about getting present with ingredient for Barrufia elixir. It's in level 25.
Same problem here. I agree we could unlock it from the left too, but as it is on one line, it has to be available from the right as well. Otherwise, the tree has to be shown differently!
@HPWUrobert still waiting on your reply. You came here and responded, with a definitive answer no less. My query to your answer is going unanswered, an answer is required. You cannot make a statement of fact that flows contrary in other parts of the tree, if we can only move down and to the right, it would negate many parts of the skill tree. Herd immunity is connected both left and right, and I chose a path that negated the cost of the DoD but at cost of guides in areas I did not need to spend them in order t9 get to herd immunity. I definitely require an answer to this, as it flows contrary to other parts of the skill tree!
Can you clarify that herd immunity is not suppose to be available coming from the right node ad Infinitum?
Herd immunity is unable to unlock via ad infinitum because the line is unidirectional and gets unlocked through clarion call. I escalated a request to update herd immunity and other similar nodes, and that request is in review with no ETA.
I have a link to the Help Immunity task from the right side. The game won’t let me do the task to boost my Wonder of the Wizarding World Power. This really needs to be dealt with before the Wonder Weekend.
Herd Immunity should open from the left and right. No reason not too. We all wasted a bunch of resources this week to get to the Herd Immunity node. I hope they fix this asap. Especially with the weekend wizarding event focused on Wonders of the Wizarding World. Total bummer
I’m wondering if I’m missing something here. I unlocked the Previous node so that I could activate this one but it’s still locked. I didn’t think that I should have to unlock the one to the left of it as well? Any ideas? Thanks!
@HPWUrobert Adding my voice to the calls that if the node can't (won't?) be fixed to unlock from both sides, as happens in many other places, then there needs to be some indication on the line that indicates that it is unidirectional so people know what is going on there.
There is small problem in Training tree, see the picture attached (see the arrow). So the link that arrow is pointing to doesn't work. As you can see I have enough material to solve the "The Businessman" node (left), but there is no red dot there and I can't resolve this node... Since there is connection between "The Businessman" and "Hot Mess" node I should be able to resolve the node, but I can't. So it looks like there is no connection between those two nodes, but there is.
Can you please check this and fix it. Either make node resolvable, or remove link (and move nodes).
Will this be fixed in the 2.15 update? It's very misleading in several areas of the tree, and in some cases you can spend a lot of resources, only to realize you can't get where you wanted to go, and it was all a bit of a waste. With all the other errors also upsetting the user base lately I'm surprised this isn't getting more attention.
The skill which you can see at the right (affecting the Exstimulo Potion) should be unlocked since I have mastered the skill in the middle which is connected to it.
Yeah... a lot of us reported this a while ago, their only response was that it can only be opened from the left and refused to explajn why it clearly appears it should open from the right as well.
If there are unidirectional parts of the tech please give us a visual indicator for these nodes. It feels strange to have to read up on tech forums to see how the nodes work. This seems to be an on going issue for over a month with no visual update.
If the developers say things are working as intended but multiple users are reporting it as a bug or are confused by the interface/interaction some change should be implemented to address the confusion.
Comments
After I unlocked the Inn Charm, I should have been able to use the Spell Mastery, but it is not unlocking.
The note "Herd Immunity" in Calamity Essentials III is still locked even though I have unlocked the prevoius notes and have enough and field guides and ministry manuals to upgrade it.
Huawei P20, Androit 10
Update 2.14.0, downloaded from Google Play
Have same issue attempting to unlock SOS III , level 35, HERD AMMUNITY.
Can you clarify that herd immunity is not suppose to be available coming from the right node ad Infinitum? @HPWUrobert
Please note - the answer to everyones’s question about HERD IMMUNITY is in the middle of page two from the HPWU team. It will only unlock from the left and not the right - which is completely illogical and perhaps if we continue to ask for clarification it may be changed. Why do some nodes open from left, right, up, or down but not this one??
If we have to unlock the node only from the left we need 70 DADA books which at the current rate would take 3-4 more months which doesn’t help anyone for this weekend’s event.
Sorry, I hate to be the bearer of bad news but just maybe we can get it changed?? Just maybe?? 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
more than disappointing. Not consistent with the rest of the game or nodes multi-directionality—part of the strategy of the game and use of field guides and manuals
wow. Debugging and game play should be clear and consistent at the least.
lots of energy and resources as well as time wasted.
@HPWUrobert I fully agree with the remarks @ClairabusGryff made about Herd Immunity - it is no good saying you can unlock it from the right (bllocked by loads of DADA books), when it clearly looks like it should also unlock from the left. That is how it works in 95%+ of other similar nodes.
Please respond to our remarks
Chasing waterfalls was incorrectly only open from only one approach but got fixed. Can this please be fixed as there is currently no logic to it? There are no arrows, all lines are equally valid, all should work including upwards. "Herd immunity" is super urgent for this weekend.
Hello, I've noticed a bug in SOS training in Polish version. There shows that there is greater chance of getting Exstimulo elixirs, but in description there is something about getting present with ingredient for Barrufia elixir. It's in level 25.
Have a good day
Salicee
Same problem here. I agree we could unlock it from the left too, but as it is on one line, it has to be available from the right as well. Otherwise, the tree has to be shown differently!
@HPWUrobert still waiting on your reply. You came here and responded, with a definitive answer no less. My query to your answer is going unanswered, an answer is required. You cannot make a statement of fact that flows contrary in other parts of the tree, if we can only move down and to the right, it would negate many parts of the skill tree. Herd immunity is connected both left and right, and I chose a path that negated the cost of the DoD but at cost of guides in areas I did not need to spend them in order t9 get to herd immunity. I definitely require an answer to this, as it flows contrary to other parts of the skill tree!
@HPWUrobert Please fix this NOW! Just spent 500+ field guides getting to herd immunity for it to NOT unlock.
Loads of others did this, too. We don’t all follow this.
We got there for this upcoming event. The kind of thing SOS encourages you to do—to choose what areas you boost.
Please. This is high priority. Otherwise many of us were 100% misled and tricked into spending books where we otherwise would not!
Can you clarify that herd immunity is not suppose to be available coming from the right node ad Infinitum?
Herd immunity is unable to unlock via ad infinitum because the line is unidirectional and gets unlocked through clarion call. I escalated a request to update herd immunity and other similar nodes, and that request is in review with no ETA.
I have a link to the Help Immunity task from the right side. The game won’t let me do the task to boost my Wonder of the Wizarding World Power. This really needs to be dealt with before the Wonder Weekend.
Thank you for the response
Herd Immunity should open from the left and right. No reason not too. We all wasted a bunch of resources this week to get to the Herd Immunity node. I hope they fix this asap. Especially with the weekend wizarding event focused on Wonders of the Wizarding World. Total bummer
@Flyphoenix It's a known issue. It doesn't sound like there will anything done before the weekend though. Maybe not even later.
Look here for further information:
I’m wondering if I’m missing something here. I unlocked the Previous node so that I could activate this one but it’s still locked. I didn’t think that I should have to unlock the one to the left of it as well? Any ideas? Thanks!
@HPWUrobert Adding my voice to the calls that if the node can't (won't?) be fixed to unlock from both sides, as happens in many other places, then there needs to be some indication on the line that indicates that it is unidirectional so people know what is going on there.
Another bad connection report on behalf of player 13121417 in WU Discord; Wendy Wunderwind -> Naaszty Business
Why does the encirclement remain
locked?
I thought it could be accessed from
both sides. Or at least from the middle ...
There is small problem in Training tree, see the picture attached (see the arrow). So the link that arrow is pointing to doesn't work. As you can see I have enough material to solve the "The Businessman" node (left), but there is no red dot there and I can't resolve this node... Since there is connection between "The Businessman" and "Hot Mess" node I should be able to resolve the node, but I can't. So it looks like there is no connection between those two nodes, but there is.
Can you please check this and fix it. Either make node resolvable, or remove link (and move nodes).
This skill remains locked. It appears to be accessible from two directions?
iOS 13.6
HPWU v 2.14
Will this be fixed in the 2.15 update? It's very misleading in several areas of the tree, and in some cases you can spend a lot of resources, only to realize you can't get where you wanted to go, and it was all a bit of a waste. With all the other errors also upsetting the user base lately I'm surprised this isn't getting more attention.
The skill which you can see at the right (affecting the Exstimulo Potion) should be unlocked since I have mastered the skill in the middle which is connected to it.
I am also seeing this bug.
Same here.
Yeah... a lot of us reported this a while ago, their only response was that it can only be opened from the left and refused to explajn why it clearly appears it should open from the right as well.
I opened up the AD infinitum charm node connected to the Herd Immunity node and it's still locked. Thanks for looking into it.
If there are unidirectional parts of the tech please give us a visual indicator for these nodes. It feels strange to have to read up on tech forums to see how the nodes work. This seems to be an on going issue for over a month with no visual update.
If the developers say things are working as intended but multiple users are reporting it as a bug or are confused by the interface/interaction some change should be implemented to address the confusion.